Sales include former village dentist office, lakeside property | News, Sports, Jobs

Ella Castle

OBSERVER Photo by Gregory Bacon The site at 85-89 W. Main St. sold in August for $250,000. A Fredonia property that at one time was a bank and also used to be a dentist office for children has changed hands. The Post-Journal and OBSERVER have been […]


OBSERVER Photo by Gregory Bacon
The site at 85-89 W. Main St. sold in August for $250,000.

A Fredonia property that at one time was a bank and also used to be a dentist office for children has changed hands.

The Post-Journal and OBSERVER have been analyzing real estate sales in Chautauqua County and recently looked at the transactions from Aug. 22-31.

During this time period, Mark and Michelle Twichell sold 85-89 W. Main St., Fredonia to New Erie Holding, LLC of Fredonia for $250,000.

Dr. Twichell, DDS, specialized in pediatric dentistry before he retired. Before the building was used as a dentist office, it was home to Lake Shore Savings Bank.

Today 85 West Main Street advertises that it has lease space available. The property also has on it a marker for the first natural gas well in the United States.

In a separate sale, Lodge at Chautauqua Lake LLC, of Lakewood sold 74-78 Water St., Mayville to Erie Bank of Warren, Pa. for $581,714.

This was the location of a proposed 34 unit, $17 million condominium resort by some members of the Webb family. That project was shelved in 2022.

The property is for sale. It’s listed on-line for $995,000. A sign on the property says to contact Cushman & Wakefield Pyramid Brokerage Company.

In a different transaction, 8504 East Forest Ave., Portland to Lake Erie Hidden Treasures, LLC of Ripley for $141,500. Lake Erie Hidden Treasures’ website states that it has a “rustic cottage on 2.5 secluded acres with a hidden beach cove. Enjoy swimming, kayaking and watching beautiful sunsets over Lake Erie.”

Including the sales previously mentioned, there were 14 sales that were $250,000 or higher. The remaining top sales are as follows:

– 2608 Shadyside Road, Mina sold for $690,000.

– 8 Ames Ave., Chautauqua Institution, town of Chautauqua, sold for $610,000.

– 19 Ramble Ave., Chautauqua Institution sold for $581,000.

– 786 Abbey Hill Road, Ellington sold for $565,000.

– 46 Coleman Road, Busti sold for $380,000.

– 120 Chautauqua Escapes, North Harmony sold for $377,500.

– 4186 Driftwood Road, Ellery sold for $340,201.

– 2427 Lakeside Drive, Busti sold for $310,000.

– 377 E. Main St., Fredonia sold for $280,000.

– 147 Longview Ave., Ellicott sold for $275,000.

– 3216 Hooker Road, Charlotte sold for $250,000.

– 26 Casabella Drive, Fredonia sold for $250,000.

Overall, from Aug. 22-31 there were 117 transactions. The full list of sales over $1 is as follows:

AUGUST 22-25

National Mortgage, LLC of Coppell, Texas sold 9 Water St., Sinclairville to Daniel Barker for $30,000.

Marucci Property Management, LLC of Jamestown sold five parcels in Falconer to Ideal Industrial Services, LLC of Jamestown for $95,000. Addresses include 20 Cross St. and properties on E. Elmwood Avenue.

Franklin Pagano sold 1360 Rt. 5, Silver Creek to the village of Silver Creek for $10,000.

Florence Cybart, Judith Westling and Mark Cybart sold 33 Wright Park Ave., Dunkirk to Arthur Hallett Page V for $191,250.

Budd Osborne sold 18 Arlington Ave., Jamestown to Annie Brooks for $85,000.

Thomas Whitermore sold 5523 N. Rt. 62, Ellington to Amir Khan for $20,895 and 25 Wilson Place for $8,000.

Michael and Shannon Near sold 711 Park Ave., Dunkirk to Lynette Soto for $132,500.

Kyle Pfeiffer sold 67 Lester St., Sinclairville to Chad and Chelsea Brown for $144,200.

J&G Enterprises WNY, LLC of Fredonia sold 112 S. Zebra St., Dunkirk to Annet A. Hernandez Sanchez for $95,000.

The administrator for Louis Racitano sold 52 Linwood Ave., Jamestown to Thomas Bailey Jr. for $30,000.

Rollin Reading, Kimberly Reading and Wendy Lee sold 3950 S. Clifford Ave., Ellery to Jon and Joy Steffan for $199,900.

Stephanie Buccola, Peter Fuller and Julie Pickett sold 130 Hickory St., Ellicott to David Sandquist for $139,000.

Chautauqua County Land Bank Corp. sold 129 Fairview Ave., Jamestown to CMG Development, LLC of Jamestown for $5,000.

Jeffrey Franklin sold 1739 King Road, Hanover to Danielle Mead for $65,000.

Ryanne Cessna sold 145 Lakeview Ave., Lakewood to Leanna Luka-Conley for $130,000.

Karlee Foti sold 217 E. Pearl St., Falconer to Kathleen Barmore for $19,000.

Betty DeLand sold 8 Harmon Ave., Brocton to Jennifer Rosas for $70,695.

Tracie Carlson sold 34 Douglas Place, Jamestown to James Magee for $97,000.

Linda Yartz sold 1176 Hunt Road, Busti to Wyatt and Allissa Perry for $98,000.

Daniel Komorowski sold vacant land on Summit Avenue, Ellery to Mark and Danielle Hinman for $37,500.

Daniel and Olivia Pavlock sold 3216 Hooker Road, Charlotte to Kyle Pfeiffer for $250,000.

Jennifer Miller, Colleen Brunswick, Lisa Valentine, and Daniel Brown sold 41 Market St., Dunkirk to Michael and Paula Stoiber for $191,000.

Douglas Hillerby sold 245 Fulton St., Jamestown to Jonathan Cairo for $25,000.

Leona and Edmund Elwell sold 1201 Angell Road, Hanover to Nicholas Leone for $185,000.

Stone Hill 716, LLC of Lakewood sold 346 Delaware Ave., Dunkirk to Kolnae Jones for $89,900.

Richard and Jeanne Anderson sold 46 Coleman Road, Busti to Tyler and Jeanne Nelson for $380,000.

AUG. 28-31

Richard Fisk and Donna Culver-Fisk sold 43 Chestnut St., Westfield to Lyle Fell Jr. for $185,000.

Nancy Malenga sold 46 Howard St., Jamestown to Kayleigh Brunacini for $91,000.

Christopher Veres sold 5 Orchard St., Jamestown to Tiffany Raybold for $500 and 6 Orchard St., for $1,000.

David and Amber Seekings sold 75 E. Main St., Falconer to Ashley Bobek for $165,000.

Flip Jtown, LLC of Ashville sold 4483 W. Fairmount Ave., Busti to Red State Charlie Capital, LLC of Fairfax, Virginia for $129,000.

Bear Creek Properties LP of Barrie, Ontario, Canada sold 901 Prendergast Ave. and 115 Crossman St., Jamestown to Red State Charlie Capital, LLC for $120,000.

Rick Martin sold 218.5 Newland Ave., Jamestown to Red State Charlie Capital, LLC for $80,000.

Thomas and Tammy Bollman sold 418 Falconer St., Jamestown to Red State Charlie Capital, LLC for $100,000.

Jeffrey and Leanne Homza sold 26 Casabella Drive, Fredonia to Bonnie Burmaster for $250,000.

A trustee with the Jane Currie Revocable Living Trust sold a parcel on Springbrook Road, Chautauqua town to the town of Chautauqua for $75,000.

Joseph Daum sold 910 Edgewater Drive, Westfield to Thomas Robson for $40,000.

Richard Simon sold 105 Midgley St., Jamestown to Christian Peterson for $102,000.

Aaron Leeper sold 803 Harding Ave., Jamestown to Elizua Fuentes Munoz for $45,000.

Howard F. Haskin, Howard R. Haskin and Gwendolyn Haskin sold 8504 East Forest Ave., Portland to Lake Erie Hidden Treasures, LLC of Ripley for $141,500.

Sherwood Potter and Jeanne Lyon-Potter sold 10266 Kortwright Road, Ashville, town of Harmony to Mosie and Bertha Yoder for $12,500.

Mark and Michelle Twichell sold 85-89 W. Main St., Fredonia to New Erie Holding, LLC of Fredonia for $250,000.

Leary Walker sold 27 West 10th St., Jamestown to Rene Page for $9,000.

Ashley and Nicholas Dubois sold 15 N. Ocelot St., Dunkirk to Richard Gardner and Gerald Galey II for $140,000.

William and Rochelle Petko sold a parcel on West Side Hill Road, Ripley to Marvin Troyer for $84,900.

Sarah D’Agostino, Benjamin Yount and Kristin Vogt sold 5270 Lewis Road, Ellery to Heather Schreiner, Samuel Carson and David Vogt Jr. for $42,858.

The executrix of the Estate of Frank Nelson sold 1244 Austin Hill Road, Frewsburg, town of Carroll for $80,000.

Cheap Lands Inc. of Port St. Lucie, Fla. sold 413 West Sixth St., Jamestown to Joana Sevilla for $7,600.

MCLP Asset Company of Dallas, Texas sold 15 East Pearl St., Falconer to David Brainard for $113,500.

Gregg and Susan Davis sold 786 Abbey Hill Road, Ellington to Daniel and Olivia Pavlock for $565,000.

Diana Gronquist sold 427 S. Main St., Jamestown to Tristan Myers for $85,000.

Eugene and Carol Albright sold 147 Longview Ave., Ellicott to Derek and Breanna Burdick for $275,000.

John and Sylvia Hanlon sold property on Berry Street, Fredonia to Bryan and Alycia Bongiovanni for $25,000.

Derrek Ames sold 222 Hazeltine Ave., Jamestown to Maria Ballard for $50,000.

Cascade Funding Mortgage Trust HB4 of Houston, Texas sold 338 S. Main St., Jamestown to Elisandra Torres for $57,475.

Matthew Davis sold 2994 Fluvanna Townline Road, Ellicott to Brandon Reagle for $90,000.

Celeste Lira sold 2427 Lakeside Drive, Busti to Jonathan and Megan Price for $310,000.

Lodge at Chautauqua Lake LLC, of Lakewood sold 74-78 Water St., Mayville to Erie Bank of Warren, Pa. for $581,714.

Daf Land Holdings, LLC of Forestville sold 377 E. Main St., Fredonia to Mimi and Steven Joint for $280,000.

Paul and Roseann Carlson sold 266 Lake Shore Drive West, Dunkirk to Daryl and Rebekah Frost for $95,000 and a parcel on West Chestnut Street for $5,000.

Michael and Constance Nemes sold 120 Chautauqua Escapes, North Harmony to Jodie Turri and Carl Good for $377,500.

RTV Properties, LLC of Williamsville sold 8005 Felton Road, Westfield to Rodney Houser for $64,890.

A referee for Laurie Williams sold 4437 South Hill Road, Ellington to WNY Partner Holdings, Inc. of Buffalo for $52,112.

Anthony and Janet Kapuscinski sold 26 Clinton Ave. Fredonia to Bermudez Jose Maissonet and Carmona Maria Rivera for $220,000.

Florence Minton sold 491 S. Main St., Jamestown to Michelle Ford for $65,000.

Paul and Brenda Tabone sold 42 Lambert Ave., Fredonia to Thomas Abruzzo for $130,000.

Chautauqua County Land Bank Corp. sold 115 Broadhead Ave., Jamestown to Bill Safford and Dave Bemis for $20,000.

Joelle Spencer sold 41 Royal Ave., Jamestown to John Errico and Deanne Knight for $155,355.

Meryl Streeter sold 19 Ramble Ave., Chautauqua Institution, Chautauqua town to Robert Zelin for $581,000.

Ronald Marsh sold 4 Water St., Hanover to Michael Rodgers for $25,000.

Helen Johnson sold 229 Busti Sugar Grove Road, Busti to Andrew and Carley Lata for $153,000.

A trustee with the Barbara Rait Revocable Living Trust sold 8 Ames Ave., Chautauqua Institution, town of Chautauqua, to Jerome and Kathryn Chesley for $610,000.

The executor of the Last Will and Testament of Margaret Smith sold 7960 Rt. 474, Clymer to Craig Rotunda for $88,000.

Karl and June Kimmich sold 2608 Shadyside Road, Mina to Dillon and Bethanie Stein for $690,000.

Tonie Wirsen sold 4186 Driftwood Road, Ellery to Donald and Shelly Chadwick for $340,201.



Today’s breaking news and more in your inbox







Next Post

Paxlovid unlikely contributes to COVID-19 rebound; a roundup of 2023 guidelines

January 02, 2024 1 min read Add topic to email alerts Receive an email when new articles are posted on Please provide your email address to receive an email when new articles are posted on . “ data-action=”subscribe”> Subscribe We were unable to process […]
Guidelines_Adobe Stock

Subscribe US Now

situs judi bola Daftar sekarang dengan cara klik link login slot via dana 24 jam terpercaya, join sekarang slot gacor online dengan pilihan platform game slot pragmatic play paling favorit tahun 2023. akun pro thailand idn poker